5 min read

Lead magnets: what works, what doesn’t and how to make one

A free guide, checklist or tool can turn website visitors into contacts, but only if it solves a real problem. How to create a lead magnet worth signing up for.
Lead magnet guide and checklist

Most people who visit your website aren’t ready to buy yet. They’re researching, comparing or just curious. If the only option is “contact us for a quote”, the majority will leave and you’ll never hear from them again. A good lead magnet gives some of them a reason to stay in touch.

A lead magnet gives those people a reason to leave their details now. It’s something useful you offer in exchange for an email address: a guide, a checklist, a template, a calculator, a short video course or a quick assessment.

Done well, a lead magnet builds a list of interested people you can stay in touch with until they’re ready. Done badly, it’s a PDF nobody downloads, or a list full of people who’ll never buy anything.

What makes a lead magnet work

The lead magnets that perform best tend to share a few qualities:

  • They solve one specific problem. “The complete guide to marketing” is too broad. “A checklist for choosing a wedding venue” is specific and immediately useful.
  • They’re relevant to what you sell. The people who want it should be the people who might later buy from you.
  • They’re quick to use. A one-page checklist gets used. A 60-page ebook often doesn’t.
  • The title promises a clear result. People should know exactly what they’ll get and why it helps.
  • They show your expertise. Using it should make people think “these people know what they’re talking about”.

Ideas by type of business

Some formats suit particular businesses well:

  • Trades and home services: a cost guide explaining what affects price, a “questions to ask before hiring” checklist, a seasonal maintenance calendar.
  • Professional services: a deadline calendar, a template, a short guide to a common decision, a self-assessment quiz.
  • B2B suppliers: a buyer’s guide, a specification checklist, a simple ROI calculator.
  • Retail and hospitality: a style or recipe guide, early access to launches, an invitation to a members’ list.

The best source of ideas is your inbox. What questions do prospects ask again and again before they buy? Answer one of them properly, and you’ve got a lead magnet.

A good lead magnet is the answer to a question your best prospects are already asking. If you have to explain why someone would want it, pick a different topic.

What tends to fall flat

  1. “Sign up for our newsletter”. Few people want more email for its own sake. Tell them what they’ll get.
  2. Thinly disguised brochures. If the “guide” is just a sales pitch, people notice and trust drops.
  3. Something that attracts the wrong people. A generic prize draw can bring hundreds of sign-ups from people who only want the prize.
  4. Forms that ask too much. Name and email is usually enough at this stage. Every extra field reduces sign-ups.
  5. No follow-up. Collecting contacts and then doing nothing wastes the whole exercise.

Setting it up properly

You’ll need a few pieces in place:

  • A simple landing page explaining what the lead magnet is and who it’s for
  • A short sign-up form connected to your email platform
  • An automatic email delivering it straight away
  • A short welcome sequence that follows up over the next week or two
  • Tracking so you can see sign-ups by source

Be clear about what people are signing up to. If you want to send ongoing marketing emails, the sign-up wording should say so, and consent should be freely given. Under UK rules, making marketing consent a condition of getting the download is a grey area at best, so take advice if you’re unsure, and always include an easy way to unsubscribe.

Follow up in a way that helps

The follow-up sequence is where a lead magnet turns into business. A simple pattern:

  1. Deliver the resource and say what to do with it
  2. A few days later, share a related tip or answer a common question
  3. Then share an example of your work or a customer story you’re permitted to use
  4. Then make a clear, low-pressure offer, such as a free consultation or a quote

After that, move people onto your regular emails, sent at a pace that stays useful. Track how many sign-ups become enquiries and customers, not just how many downloads you get.

Want a hand?

Our lead generation team can help you choose a topic, create the lead magnet and build the landing page and follow-up around it. If you’d like the emails to run automatically once someone signs up, that’s where our marketing automation service comes in.

Share this article
Written by the Ignite Creative team

We’re a web design, branding and marketing agency in Liverpool. These articles come from the questions clients ask us every week. If this one raised a question about your own business, send it over.

In this article
In this article
Got a question about this?

Tell us what you're working on and we'll give you a straight answer.

More on this topic

Need help with the real thing?

If an article has raised a question about your own website, brand or marketing, send us the context and we’ll take a look.